User blog comment:TheBlazingEye/Sprite under shading!/@comment-25445273-20160103235635

I might be late but it looks a little cartoony for terraria. Now granted you havn't shaded it at all yet, but it really has too rounded of a shape, and seams to give off in my opinion a comedic vibe. One reason is size to detal. The overall detail seams to make me feel if it was a smaller sprite made bigger. Again, not saying it's bad, and not saying it is a small sprite made bigger, it's just got that vibe. Another thing is the hands. They look like the hands you might find on a gravity falls character, in my opinion they are too chubby. Giving them a sleaker more pointed look chould easily give this boss a much more menicing feel. Another is the flames head thing. Terraria's sprites have a simplified realism. They look both fake and real, and then simplified down. The flames on the head are too wide, and with not enough detals on them. It's really a good sprite, it just look to chubby and cartoony for terraria's feel. If this were zoomo's sprite this would be about a phase three. Color scheme+shape, but not yet to the shapes detales. Hope this can act as a nice guideline.