Board Thread:Sprite Threads/@comment-6218837-20150707195633/@comment-25543325-20160313171949

That's a toughie. All of them are nicely detailed and pleasant to the eye, the Globe, however, lacks the near-perfect shading of the other two and so stays at a third place. Now, the Sword does have a small issue with black-bordered blade that's a really small issue and otherwise looks great and essentially won my vote. Sure, the Dreadmaster does look insanely cool although it's not really painted in Terraria style. For instance, it lacks a dark border between each distinctive, individual part like Re-Logic staff likes to throw in. It also leaves some blank space even for a boss sized monster whereas other big sprites usually try to incorporate most pixels, save for Eye of Cthulhu and the Twins.

In short, I'll take the Sword.